Muslim Civil Rights Organizations in Florida Urge Court to Block Unconstitutional Terrorism Designation

In a new lawsuit the Council on American-Islamic Relations and CAIR-Florida are asking for emergency relief

October 3, 2026 8:00 am

桃子视频Affiliate
Media Contact
125 Broad Street
18th Floor
New York, NY 10004
United States

TALLAHASSEE 鈥� On Friday, the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) and CAIR-Florida told that their civil rights work in Florida is in imminent danger after Gov. Ron DeSantis and other Cabinet officials baselessly voted to designate them as 鈥渄omestic terrorist organizations鈥� under an unconstitutional new state law. They asked the court for emergency relief to block the designation from going into effect. The filing comes in a new lawsuit the groups filed after the Florida Cabinet鈥檚 vote.

鈥淔or decades, we and CAIR-Florida have pursued a shared mission, rooted in faith, to help people understand Islam, protect civil rights, promote justice, and empower the millions of American Muslims across the country,鈥� said CAIR. 鈥淕ov. DeSantis and other officials in his cabinet have spent months targeting us for our beliefs and civil rights work for months. If this unjustifiable designation is allowed to go into effect, our speech will be silenced, our advocacy will be halted, and our doors will be shut in Florida. This harms not only CAIR and CAIR-Florida, but all Floridians who believe in a vibrant constitutional democracy where people of all religious traditions can thrive.鈥�

Under HB 1471, five Florida executive officials have the power to designate and debilitate U.S. groups鈥攊ncluding nonprofits engaged in First Amendment-protected advocacy鈥攚ithout filing charges, initiating judicial proceedings, proving their case beyond a reasonable doubt, submitting the case to a jury, or complying with any of the other constitutional requirements of the criminal legal system. As the lawsuit explains, 鈥淭he new regime transforms Florida鈥檚 Governor, Chief of Domestic Security, and Cabinet into judge, jury, and nonprofit executioner.鈥�

Once designated, an elaborate set of prohibitions makes it a serious crime for the targeted American organization to do virtually anything in the state, and for others to work for or otherwise actively associate with it. The consequences of violating these prohibitions are severe, including up to life imprisonment. As a result of designation, an organization鈥檚 lawful, constitutionally protected speech and association are immediately rendered illegal and impossible鈥攕imply because a handful of state o铿僣ials say so.

鈥淲e鈥檙e asking for urgent judicial intervention to prevent CAIR and CAIR-Florida from becoming the first casualties of Florida鈥檚 unconstitutional and draconian new law,鈥� said Hina Shamsi, director of ACLU鈥檚 National Security Project. 鈥淭he Constitution does not allow officials to punish U.S. organizations and deny them due process because of disagreement with their views, yet Florida鈥檚 Governor and Cabinet did so anyway. It鈥檚 hard to overstate the stakes here, not only for our clients, but also for other nonprofits and corporations that Florida officials may decide they dislike and want to target in the future.鈥�

CAIR and CAIR-Florida initially challenged their designation under the new Florida law in a suit filed on July 1, the day the law went into effect, and Gov. DeSantis said he and other Cabinet officials would move quickly to designate CAIR. On October 1, the court dismissed their initial case, finding that the nonprofits did not have standing in July because their fears of harm were speculative. Hours later, counsel for CAIR and CAIR-Florida filed a new complaint, explaining that Gov. DeSantis and other Cabinet members had followed through on their threats and voted to designate CAIR and CAIR-Florida on September 29, 2026.

The complaint makes clear that this designation violates the non-profits鈥� First Amendment rights, as well as their right to due process and right to counsel. Targeted organizations receive no meaningful notice and have no meaningful opportunity to defend themselves before the designation and harsh penalties take effect. Florida鈥檚 law is also preempted by federal law.

鈥淲ithout evidence, fair notice, or any opportunity to respond, Florida officials have arbitrarily and unjustly branded CAIR and CAIR-Florida with the scarlet letter of a 'DTO' designation, effectively rendering them pariahs.鈥� said Scott McCoy, deputy legal director, Southern Poverty Law Center. 鈥淭his designation is a political act that violates the First Amendment and due process rights of two nonprofit organizations that have served Floridians for more than 25 years. If state officials can do this to CAIR and CAIR-Florida with impunity, they can do it to any organization whose message they dislike.鈥�

The designation, which effectively criminalizes the existence of any labeled organization, is set to go into effect on November 5. If it does, the impact on CAIR and CAIR-Florida would be immediate and devastating. In their October 2 motion for emergency relief, the nonprofits are asking that the court order Florida officials to rescind their designation of CAIR and CAIR-Florida and prevent it from going into effect. In the alternative, they are asking the court to prevent Florida state prosecutors from enforcing the law鈥檚 harsh penalties against the nonprofits and third parties connected with them.

The impact on the Floridian communities CAIR and CAIR-Florida serve would also be immense. CAIR-Florida provides a range of pro bono legal services to Florida residents, including those who su铿�er government and workplace discrimination in violation of their civil rights, as well as those navigating the immigration system. They help register people to vote, dispel and counter false stereotypes, prejudices, and disinformation, of Muslims, and advocate for human rights. For example, CAIR and CAIR-Florida supported the campaign to bring back Mohammed Ibrahim鈥攁 16-year-old U.S. citizen from Florida鈥攚ho was unjustly detained by Israel in February 2025 for almost ten months.

鈥淣o state government should hold the power to unilaterally extinguish domestic advocacy organizations because of their First Amendment-protected activity," said Daniel Tilley, legal director, 桃子视频of Florida. 鈥�Our democracy depends on freedom of speech and association and is fueled by those who advocate for their communities. For decades, CAIR and CAIR-Florida have sought to support a vibrant constitutional democracy where people of all religious traditions can thrive. This baseless designation will substantially harm the thousands of American Muslims who rely on CAIR鈥檚 advocacy 鈥� and we refuse to let it stand.鈥�

CAIR and CAIR-Florida have done nothing to deserve this devastating designation. As the complaint explains, the state has never indicted, much less convicted, either CAIR or CAIR-Florida under any criminal law鈥攁nd certainly not a criminal law involving the serious charge of terrorism. If the state tried, it would fail. The reason is simple: neither CAIR nor CAIR-Florida is engaged in terrorist activity, and the state would be unable to prove its case in a court of law.

CAIR and CAIR-Florida are represented by the ACLU, 桃子视频of Florida, the Southern Poverty Law Center, and Bondurant Mixson & Elmore LLP.


Related 桃子视频