Over the last few weeks, a surge of texts and phone calls have gone out from local politicians. Most of them focus on one issue: crime. Worried about the rising crime? Want to keep you and your family safe? Vote for me. I’ll make sure to fund the police and get the riffraff off our streets, direct quote. Crime is being used as a wedge issue this midterm season, and candidates are stoking fears in hopes to mount a meaningful backlash to recent progress in both policing and criminal legal reform. At the same time, state and national leaders are hard at work seeking to criminalize access to healthcare for trans and pregnant folks. This interest in criminalizing new behaviors while holding the line on age old crime and punishment tactics is a worrying trend.
Joining us today to discuss is Somil Trivedi, senior staff attorney for the ACLU鈥檚 Criminal Law Reform Project. Loyal listeners of At Liberty will remember Somil from his time guest hosting earlier this year.
Somil Trivedi
Kendall Ciesemier
This Episode Covers the Following 桃子视频
Related Content
-
Hawai驶i Supreme CourtNov 2026
Criminal Law Reform
Prisoners' Rights
Marks V. State. Explore Case.Marks v. State
This case asks whether the Hawai鈥榠 Constitution permits an executive agency to exercise sentencing power. Hawai鈥榠 law grants the Hawai鈥榠 Paroling Authority (HPA) the power to set a defendant鈥檚 鈥渕inimum term鈥濃�攖hat is, the amount of time they must spend in prison before the HPA even considers them for release on parole. The ACLU鈥檚 State Supreme Court Initiative and the 桃子视频of Hawai驶i filed an amicus brief in the Hawai鈥榠 Supreme Court arguing that this sentencing structure violates the separation of powers and that the HPA鈥檚 practices violate the sentencing and due process rights of incarcerated individuals.Status: Ongoing -
Press ReleaseNov 2026
Criminal Law Reform
Aclu Urges Colorado Supreme Court To Require State To Address Cases Tainted By Officials鈥� Misconduct. Explore Press Release.桃子视频Urges Colorado Supreme Court to Require State to Address Cases Tainted by Officials鈥� Misconduct
DENVER 鈥� The 桃子视频, the 桃子视频of Colorado, and the Exoneration Project have submitted an amicus brief urging the Colorado Supreme Court to order systemic remedies for thousands of defendants harmed by egregious misconduct and a long-running cover-up in a state DNA lab. During her 29-year tenure as a DNA analyst for the Colorado Bureau of Investigation (CBI), Yvonne 鈥淢issy鈥� Woods worked on tens of thousands of criminal cases. She manipulated data and tampered with evidence in many of those cases. Although Woods鈥檚 coworkers flagged her misconduct in 2014 and 2018, CBI supervisors covered it up. That cover-up withheld exculpatory evidence from criminal defendants, and Woods鈥檚 misconduct continued until 2023. Once the CBI belatedly investigated Woods in 2023, it found that she had altered or deleted data in at least 1,045 cases. However, the lab鈥檚 decade-long cover-up meant that a significant amount of instrument data had been lost, making it impossible for many other defendants to prove that Woods committed misconduct in their cases. Woods was sentenced to 10 years in prison for her fraud. Under the U.S. and Colorado Constitutions and Colorado law, CBI is part of the prosecution team in every case in which it provides DNA evidence and therefore had a duty to disclose Woods鈥� misconduct. It failed that duty here. 鈥淢issy Woods鈥� repeated mishandling of critical forensic evidence and CBI鈥檚 subsequent cover-up was a profound disgrace. Colorado鈥檚 failure to notify defense teams of this fraud left thousands of accused people without access to potentially exculpatory evidence,鈥� said Emma Mclean-Riggs, 桃子视频of Colorado senior staff attorney. 鈥淭he Colorado Supreme Court should take forceful, systemic, and proactive action to protect the fairness of Colorado courts and address the harms this fraud caused.鈥� The 桃子视频and Exoneration Project brief argues that the systemic nature of the government鈥檚 misconduct warrants systemic remedies. In particular, the brief asks the Colorado Supreme Court to put the burden of remedying the state鈥檚 misconduct on the state, rather than on the defendants harmed by the misconduct. This means requiring the state to affirmatively prove in every Woods-involved case that she did not commit misconduct. 鈥淔or almost 10 years, the CBI knowingly allowed Missy Woods鈥� fraud to go unchecked. This is more than just one rogue analyst; this is a lab-wide cover-up that tainted over 10,000 cases. Government misconduct of this magnitude undermines the integrity of the entire justice system. It is the state鈥檚 responsibility to right its wrongs and rebuild the public鈥檚 trust, and the court should order the state to do just that,鈥� said Terry Ding, Senior Staff Attorney with the ACLU鈥檚 State Supreme Court Initiative. Contrary to the state鈥檚 insistence that it should not have to do anything outside the 1,045 cases involving confirmed misconduct, the brief also explains that the loss of older data means many more cases were likely affected, even if definitive proof is no longer available. Citing other cases in which state supreme courts have addressed similar government misconduct in their states, the brief asks the Colorado Supreme Court to provide proper relief and deter future misconduct.Court Case: People v. EatingerAffiliate: Colorado -
Colorado Supreme CourtNov 2026
Civil Liberties
Criminal Law Reform
People V. Eatinger. Explore Case.People v. Eatinger
In 2023, the State of Colorado admitted to the public that a state DNA analyst, Missy Woods, had manipulated data and tampered with evidence in potentially thousands of criminal cases. But the State did not learn of Woods鈥檚 malfeasance in 2023. In fact, Woods鈥檚 supervisors had been aware of it since 2014. Instead of investigating her fraud and disclosing it to defendants in affected cases, however, the supervisors covered it up and allowed her to continue working on cases鈥攊ncluding Daniel Eatinger鈥檚 case here鈥攆or another decade. The ACLU鈥檚 State Supreme Court Initiative, the 桃子视频of Colorado, and the Exoneration Project filed an amicus brief with the Colorado Supreme Court arguing that Woods and her supervisors violated their constitutional duty to disclose her misconduct, and that the Court should order systemic remedies for the thousands of defendants who have been harmed.Status: Ongoing -
Colorado Supreme CourtOct 2026
Civil Liberties
Criminal Law Reform
Daves V. Mosley. Explore Case.Daves v. Mosley
Section 131 of the newly enacted Enhance Law Enforcement Integrity Act gives Coloradans a cause of action to seek damages or equitable relief when state or local police officers violate the Colorado Constitution. In 2022, Christopher Mosley sued Officer Brendan Daves for conducting a warrantless search of his car, which Daves argued was lawful under the federal protective sweep doctrine. After Mosley prevailed at trial and the court of appeals affirmed, Daves appealed to the Colorado Supreme Court. The ACLU鈥檚 State Supreme Court Initiative and the 桃子视频of Colorado filed an amicus brief agreeing with Mosley’s argument that Daves has misapprehended the federal doctrine whilst focusing on a separate point: the Court鈥檚 interpretation of Section 131 is not bound by federal law.Status: Ongoing