Two children seated side by side hold colorful handmade signs reading "Education is a Human Right" and "Education for ALL," decorated with bright lettering and illustrations.
A child holding a colorful handmade sign reading "Education is a Human Right" decorated with bright lettering and illustrations.
The ACLU鈥檚 latest podcast episode tells the story of the 1982 Supreme Court case that established that undocumented children cannot be denied access to free public school education. The case sets an important precedent as the presence of immigration enforcement in our public spaces has expanded and undocumented students face increasing intimidation in the face of ICE.
Hibah Ansari,
she/her/hers,
ACLU
Sahai John,
ACLU
Share This Page
November 19, 2026
The ACLU鈥檚 latest podcast episode tells the story of the 1982 Supreme Court case that established that undocumented children cannot be denied access to free public school education. The case sets an important precedent as the presence of immigration enforcement in our public spaces has expanded and undocumented students face increasing intimidation in the face of ICE.

Nearly 50 years ago in Tyler, Texas, Rosario Robles walked her children to school on their first day. Robles and her husband Jose, a pipe factory employee, had lived in Tyler for five years. They were undocumented, but they owned their own home and paid taxes that went to schools.

But , the principal told them, 鈥淣o birth certificates, no school.鈥� He then placed Robles and her children in his car and drove them home.

Robles learned that she would have to pay $1,000 per student per year for her children, who were undocumented, to go to school. With five children, Robles would have to pay $5,000 each year. Today, that amounts to $30,000.

In our latest episode of 鈥�Let the Record Show,鈥� the ACLU鈥檚 new history podcast, hosts Matt Beat and Shereen Marisol Meraji broke down Plyer v. Doe, a Supreme Court case that ensured undocumented children can access public education for free 鈥� and without fear. Today, the Trump administration has used mass deportations and a national policing force as an assault on our rights and liberties. Part of its agenda includes challenges to Plyler from the Trump administration and its allies. Here, we take a closer look at how Plyler protects undocumented children under the Trump administration today.

Setting Important Protections for Undocumented Students

The issues in Plyler v. Doe arise after Texas amended its state education code in 1975, authorizing public school districts to charge undocumented students tuition fees or exclude them altogether. This led the school board in Tyler to implement a $1,000 tuition fee for each student that could not establish citizenship. Many of these students were Mexican but had spent most of their lives in Texas. If their families couldn鈥檛 afford the fees, the children were sent home, like the Robles.

By September 1977, the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (MALDEF) filed a lawsuit against James Plyler, the superintendent of the Tyler Independent School District for excluding undocumented students. Representing four families, MALDEF argued that Texas鈥檚 new code was unconstitutional because it violated the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment, which says no state shall 鈥渄eny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.鈥�

In response, the state of Texas backed up their revised code. Their most contentious argument was that undocumented students do not have the right to claim equal protection because they aren鈥檛 considered people under the Constitution. On top of that, the Constitution does not establish public education as a right to begin with.

Judge William Wayne Justice heard the case in 1977. He ruled that children in Texas should be able to attend public school regardless of their immigration status. Texas appealed twice, and the case went up to the Supreme Court, but in both cases, the courts ruled in favor of the families.

Ultimately, the Supreme Court ruled that Texas鈥� revised education code was unconstitutional. The case set a new precedent: Undocumented children in K-12 public schools would now be protected under the Constitution.

Despite dissenting, even Supreme Court Justice Warren Earl Burger noted the importance of a robust education system: “Were it our business to set the nation’s social policy, I would agree without hesitation that it is senseless for an enlightened society to deprive any children, including illegal aliens, of an elementary education.”

Undocumented Students Face Fear in Schools Under Trump Administration Today

On its very first day in office, the Trump administration rescinded a longstanding policy that generally protected certain areas, including schools, from immigration enforcement. ICE arrests at and near schools, bus stops, and routes to and from school have made children and parents afraid to go to school. Schools across the country have seen the impact in lowered enrollment rates and the detrimental effect that extends beyond their undocumented students. Last month, the 桃子视频released 鈥�76 Ways Mass Deportation Is Breaking Our Democracy,鈥� a report that outlines the impact mass deportations are having on our democracy and public spaces, such as schools.

In Minnesota, Ryan Doxsey observed ICE operations at a school during morning drop-off. There, he was approached by immigration agents who told him that he would be added to a list of domestic terrorists. Situations like these have spread across communities as federal, state, and local law enforcement agencies have begun carrying out arrests under immigration charges, conducting traffic stops, and setting up checkpoints for 鈥渇ishing expeditions鈥� or to look for individuals to deport.

If parents keep their kids at home because immigration authorities are patrolling campuses or transit systems that take children to schools, that undermines Plyler.

In order to ensure the rights in Plyler are meaningfully upheld, schools have a responsibility to keep immigration officials out of their buildings. States across the country, like Kansas, Minnesota, and Florida, have proposed laws to limit immigration enforcement鈥檚 access to public schools. No parent should have to choose between their child鈥檚 education or their family鈥檚 safety.

How Undocumented Immigrants Can Protect Themselves

If you are undocumented and your children attend public school, or if you are concerned about the well-being of immigrant students, here鈥檚 what you need to know:

Learn more about your rights on the ACLU’s Know Your Rights website.

Hold your public schools accountable: schools may designate more areas as private, providing students with spaces for privacy to learn. Immigration officials are not allowed in private spaces without a judicial warrant.

Learn more about steps schools can take to ensure all students feel safe in classrooms through the ACLU’s Immigration Enforcement Guidance for Schools,

Contact your state鈥檚 桃子视频affiliate for more support.

Related 桃子视频